This blog will review the original 48 What A Cartoon shorts, made by Cartoon Network in 1995. Each entry will feature a detailed review, credits, screenshots, and some tidbits and things worthy of note.
Wednesday, June 19, 2013
Shake & Flick in: "Raw Deal in Rome"
Directed by: Eugene Mattos
Written and Created by: Michael Rann, Eugene Mattos & George Johnson
Art Director: Butch Hartman
Background Stylist: Tim Maloney
Music: Bill Fulton
Produced in Association with: Fil-Cartoons, Inc., Philippines and Mr. Big Cartoons, Australia
This short is a rather odd entry, and by that, I mean it's one of the weirdest cartoons I've seen in my life. It has an incredibly simple setup, but uses stuff like wild takes and exaggerated poses ramped up to eleven, which makes this cartoon quite interesting to watch and analyze from a visual standpoint. The problem is when you bring everything together, there's something that doesn't feel right here. Call it "a mess" if you will, it wouldn't be totally inaccurate.
A vicious flea named Flick is looking for someone or some dog to have a bite, and on his way spots a billboard advertising Shake the Dog in concert. After Flick interrupts Shake's lyre performance by diving into his fur and biting him, things escalate into a musical showdown, a chase through the streets of Rome, and a chariots race at a Colosseum. Eventually Shake makes it back to the stage he was originally going to perform in, only to be caught by Flick and eaten whole.
So we have an okay premise and setup. Dogs and fleas are natural enemies, so coupled with good gags and animation it should make a fine cartoon. The cartoon is also done entirely on pantomime, giving it a very "Tom & Jerry" feel. It's fitting, for the most part.
The character of Flick is greatly established, showing him wrecking havoc as he hops around and never reacting to anything around him, aside from when he grows into a monster-like creature with humongous mouth and teeth whenever Shake is around. He's an absolute badass, and if anyone deserves the title of WAC's Resident BAMF (Google it), it's probably him.
Then there's Shake, which despite having an interesting design (it's not often we see a male poodle), is actually the source of most of the problems with this cartoon. He is shown mostly as a calm, gentleman-like character, but sometimes he would do these wild takes as if he would be scared or surprised by something. For no reason. It's like they were trying to establish him as some sort of nervous wreck, but within context of the cartoon I don't see why they felt the need to do this. And this is the cause of the short's biggest flaw. The wild takes and exaggerated faces are great from an artistic point of view, but they're inserted into the cartoon horribly. Most don't either fit for the situation, or are ridiculously over-the-top. I'll save the examples for the screenshots section, which by the way, is pretty big for this entry.
Then there's the humor. There are some really funny moments in this cartoon, my favorite being the chariot race with Shake getting run over by Flick on every lap. Flick rides a ridiculously large motorbike, while Shake is seen with every sort of pathetic vehicle desperately trying to avoid Flick every time, with no luck. This part is really well timed, and it's hilarious how Shake is shown pathetic from every angle, with the trumpets blowing right next to him, a wheel on his cart falling before the race even begins, and his "pants" dropping on every shot. The music that plays here is great too, so I think I'll give a thumbs up to Bill Fulton, who did a good job on the whole cartoon. But then you have jokes like when Flick bites Shake and he is sent flying up to the skies where he kisses a Roman Goddess, which angers a nearby Roman God, causing Shake to be struck by lightning. I guess it's creative, but it's really random and I don't buy the setup either. It's like they have this great idea for a gag but they don't know how to insert it into the cartoon.
I guess in the end I'm not exactly sure how I feel about this short. I really, REALLY want to like it, because it's artistically amazing, but too many things bring it down when you place the whole product together. It definitely deserves a watching, I'll give it that, since its style is pretty unique and it's definitely fitting if you're looking to watch something different. So yeah, don't throw this one into the garbage based on this review. Who knows, it may end up being one of your favorites.
Best part of being done with this short is that starting with the next one, we have a streak of near-perfect shorts for a while.
I like the introduction of Flick, showing his badass and vicious nature right away as all the columns fall as he jumps through the street and then when he grows the giant fangs upon seeing Shake's billboard.
This is the first example of the unfitting wild takes I mentioned. Shake is introduced reading a magazine while waiting for his hair to be done. However, he does this weird wild take, then relaxes a bit, then does an even wilder take. Why is he reacting like this? There aren't any voiceovers or noises (outside of the background music) that will cause him to go like that. Maybe he IS reacting to the background music, but there's nothing that indicates if it's part of the setting or just meant for the audience. I'm guessing he's being called on stage, but why not add something to denote this better? A voiceover, or an alarm with a nearby screen for him to look at? And even with all that, it still doesn't explain his reaction in the last screenshot, that one definitely feels random for the sake of randomness.
I do like the joke with Shake following the reflectors, mainly because of his frustrated expression when whoever is handling the lights finally gets it right.
Flick's vicious expressions is definitely something you don't notice in detail until you freeze-frame. This particular shot looks terrifying.
Oddly, Shake's reaction when he's first bitten by Flick is not nearly as exaggerated as his previous one when he's called on stage.
This gag starts out fine with Shake sabotaging Flick's harp playing by destroying it with a catapult, but then he brings in a steamroller and a robotic suit that fires a beam. It goes too long, which kinda kills it. I do like Shake's satisfied face as he sweeps the remains, though.
The music showdown is a pretty good scene, but the best part is the end where Flick plays the electric guitar at full power, blowing out Shake's fur and flesh, followed by his skeleton. The part where the fur and flesh join back with the bones is pretty gross, but it's done well.
As I said, this gag is too random, but I do like the looks on Shake as he's struck by lightning. I'm guessing the mythical figures here are Mars and Venus, but I'm not sure. If you're good with Roman mythology, feel free to enlighten me.
Flick is too awesome to be fooled by such a lame disguise.
This is a good expression, but also pretty random. I guess it means Flick is driving Shake nuts, but I don't know, it still feels rather off.
This scene I find a bit disturbing. Flick is swallowed by the engine of a flying plane, causing the plane to crash while Flick hops out intact. Maybe I'm looking too much into this, but it rather bothers me when vehicles that are presumably filled with people crash in cartoons (although it's not too bad here, I've definitely seen worse examples).
The scene where Shake desperately waits for the elevator while Flick slowly approaches is actually pretty well timed.
I also like the brief moment with Shake in the elevator and a gladiator and a lion enter it as he goes up. It's a funny shot.
Love the pathetic sight of Shake as he gets the worst chariot during the race.
What did I tell you guys? Total BAMF.
I love this whole sequence. It's very fast-paced, and despite Shake getting brutally injured at every shot, the execution and timing actually do make it fun to watch. I particularly love Shake's last attempt to continue in the race, wearing a propeller hat while "London Bridge" plays, only to be run over one last time by Flick.
I won't deny the first two expressions are terrific, but they are way too over-the-top for the situation. Shake's expression in the last screenshot as he's about to be eaten is a lot less exaggerated, which makes it all the more mind-boggling.
Also, one more thing I didn't mention in the review proper, but just remembered. This cartoon credits two animation studios, and while Fil-Cartoons was the go-to studio for most WAC shorts, I believe this is the only short that credits Mr. Big under "Produced in Association with". Maybe this has something to do with the huge switches in poses and animation? I don't know, but Mr. Big was just coming out of Ren & Stimpy at this time, so maybe they handled the more exaggerated scenes in the cartoon? I would like to know more about what happened here.
Fortunately, Shake was still able to escape after the iris out.
Subscribe to: Post Comments (Atom)
I believe Mr. Big did the layouts and Fil-Cartoons did the animation. That was the arrangement with "2 Stupid Dogs" (with animation done at Wang Films) and even one of the "Tom and Jerry Kids" episodes (Big in Australia did the layouts, while the animation was done in Hollywood. An odd arrangement)ReplyDelete
Funny they couldn't keep the layouts in-house that time.Delete
There was only a certain number of times that I could watch the S&F shorts before coming to a realization: these films are MEANSPIRITED. Flick came to strike me as just this arational abject asshole. He didn't give a damn about the soulwrecks he was imposing upon Shake. I just came to feel so damn bad for Shake. Shake didn't at all deserve the evil-ass crap Flick did to him.ReplyDelete
Shake & Flick has been my #1 favorite WPT/WAC! short since the first time I've seen it.ReplyDelete
While the facial expressions of Shake seemed out of place, the visuals and timing of the gags helped pull it through. A great WAC short.ReplyDelete
This was a weird short, but it had some decent animation to keep it going. I liked how ridiculous things kept getting (like the way Shake destroyed Flick's harp, or Flick's cool electric guitar setup and motorcycle.)ReplyDelete
I remember as a kid recording some goofy commentary on it with a tape recorder set up to the TV. For the plane scene, as it flew into the scene, I began speaking in some kind of goofy voice...
"Look, here comes a cool jet airplane!"
*Flick flies into the plane engine and it begins spinning*
"Oh no he broke the engine! It's gonna smash! ... It's gonna blow up!"
*in normal voice* "That's the end of the jet."